docs(roadmap): add #409 — init artifact schema redundancy; skip_reason absent

ROADMAP.md

@@ -6301,4 +6301,4 @@ Original filing (2026-04-18): the session emitted `SessionStart hook (completed)
 380. **Top-level `tokens --help --output-format json` hangs with zero stdout/stderr instead of returning bounded command help JSON** — dogfooded 2026-04-30 for the 02:30 nudge on current `origin/main` / rebuilt `./rust/target/debug/claw` with embedded `git_sha` `d95b230c`. After verifying #358 covered `cost --help`, a fresh adjacent probe on the token-budget surface showed the same silent failure class: repeated bounded runs of `timeout 8 ./rust/target/debug/claw tokens --help --output-format json` exited `124` with `stdout=0` and `stderr=0`. In the same rebuilt binary, `version --output-format json` returned promptly with version/build metadata, proving the binary itself and JSON output path are reachable. This is distinct from #358's cost help hang: the affected surface is the sibling `tokens` command help, which agents use before estimating prompt/session token budgets. **Required fix shape:** (a) make `tokens --help --output-format json` return static/bounded stdout JSON with `kind:"help"` or `kind:"tokens"`, `action:"help"`, usage, options, examples, supported output formats, and related slash/direct commands; (b) ensure help rendering does not initialize slow token accounting, session, or provider state; (c) if any dynamic provider is consulted, return a typed JSON timeout/unavailable error instead of hanging; (d) add regression coverage proving tokens help in JSON mode returns within a deterministic budget. **Why this matters:** token budgeting is a preflight clawability surface. If help hangs silently, automation cannot safely discover how to inspect or constrain token usage before running expensive prompts, and budget-aware wrappers stall at the discovery step. Source: gaebal-gajae dogfood follow-up for the 02:30 nudge on rebuilt `./rust/target/debug/claw` `d95b230c`.
 381. **Top-level `cache --help --output-format json` hangs with zero stdout/stderr instead of returning bounded command help JSON** — dogfooded 2026-04-30 for the 03:00 nudge on current `origin/main` / rebuilt `./rust/target/debug/claw` with embedded `git_sha` `d95b230c`. After #358 and #380 landed for the cost/tokens preflight help hangs, a fresh adjacent probe on the cache-control surface showed the same silent failure class: repeated bounded runs of `timeout --kill-after=1s 8s ./rust/target/debug/claw cache --help --output-format json` exited `124` with `stdout=0` and `stderr=0`. In the same rebuilt binary, `version --output-format json` returned promptly with version/build metadata, proving the binary itself and JSON output path are reachable. This is distinct from the separate `/cache` slash-command envelope mismatch class: the affected surface here is top-level `cache` command help, where agents need bounded local discovery before deciding whether to inspect, clear, or summarize cache state. **Required fix shape:** (a) make `cache --help --output-format json` return static/bounded stdout JSON with `kind:"help"` or `kind:"cache"`, `action:"help"`, usage, options, examples, supported output formats, and related slash/direct commands; (b) ensure help rendering does not initialize slow cache/session/provider state; (c) if any dynamic provider is consulted, return a typed JSON timeout/unavailable error instead of hanging; (d) add regression coverage proving cache help in JSON mode returns within a deterministic budget. **Why this matters:** cache inspection and cleanup are recovery/control-plane operations. If cache help hangs silently, claws cannot safely discover cache semantics before attempting cleanup, and automation stalls before it can choose a non-destructive cache action. Source: gaebal-gajae dogfood follow-up for the 03:00 nudge on rebuilt `./rust/target/debug/claw` `d95b230c`.
 
-417. **`mcp show <nonexistent> --output-format json` returns `found:false` + `status:"ok"` with exit 0 — a "not found" result with a success status is contradictory and causes automation to false-positive** — dogfooded 2026-04-30 by Jobdori on `e939777f`. Running `claw mcp show nonexistent --output-format json` when the server is not configured returns `{"action":"show","config_load_error":null,"found":false,"kind":"mcp","message":"server \`nonexistent\` is not configured","server_name":"nonexistent","status":"ok","working_directory":"..."}` with exit code 0. `found:false` means the server does not exist in config; `status:"ok"` means the show operation completed without internal error — but these two fields give conflicting signals: a claw checking `if status == "ok" then server_is_present` will false-positive on every nonexistent server query. The only unambiguous signal is `found:false`, but `status:"ok"` directly contradicts it. `exit 0` compounds this: standard CLI convention is exit 1 for "not found" lookups. **This is distinct from ROADMAP #102** which covers the deeper liveness-probe gap (server configured but command unreachable); #417 targets the simpler semantic contradiction in the `show` response when the server is not configured at all. **Required fix shape:** (a) use `status:"not_found"` (or `"missing"`) instead of `status:"ok"` when `found:false`; (b) exit with a non-zero code (exit 1 or exit 2) when the queried server is not found, consistent with standard lookup-command semantics; (c) if `status:"ok"` is intentionally reserved for "the show command itself ran without error" (not "the server exists"), rename it to `query_status:"ok"` and add a separate `found_status:"not_found"|"found"` field to prevent ambiguity; (d) add regression coverage proving `mcp show <nonexistent> --output-format json` returns a non-ok or semantically distinct status and a non-zero exit code. **Why this matters:** automation that orchestrates MCP server checks before starting a session will loop over a server list with `mcp show` and check `status`. If `status:"ok"` means "command ran OK" not "server exists", every missing server looks healthy to a standard status-check loop. Source: Jobdori live dogfood, `e939777f`, 2026-04-30.
+409. **`init --output-format json` emits redundant parallel artifact schemas — `artifacts[].status` and flat `created[]`/`skipped[]`/`updated[]` arrays carry identical state, and `artifacts[].status:"skipped"` omits `skip_reason`** — dogfooded 2026-04-30 by Jobdori on `e939777f`. Running `claw init --output-format json` on a fresh directory returns a JSON object with two parallel representations of the same artifact set: (1) `artifacts: [{name, status}]` — a structured per-artifact array; and (2) `created: [...]`, `skipped: [...]`, `updated: [...]` — flat string arrays partitioned by status. Both encode the same four artifact names and their outcomes with no additional information between them. On a subsequent run in an already-initialized directory, every artifact has `status:"skipped"`, but no `reason` field is present on any artifact entry — automation cannot distinguish `"already_exists"` (safe to ignore) from `"permission_denied"`, `"dry_run"`, or `"conflicting_contents"` (each requiring a different response). The `message` field also embeds `"skipped (already exists)"` prose that is absent from the structured payload. **Required fix shape:** (a) pick one canonical artifact representation — either `artifacts[{name, status, reason?, path?}]` or the flat status arrays — and deprecate the other; (b) add a `skip_reason` or `reason` field to `artifacts[]` entries with `status:"skipped"` and `status:"error"`, using an enum such as `already_exists`, `permission_denied`, `dry_run`, `conflict`, `unknown`; (c) add optional `path` (absolute) to each artifact entry so automation can act on the real on-disk location without re-joining with `project_path`; (d) add regression coverage proving `init --output-format json` on an existing directory includes machine-classifiable skip reasons for every skipped artifact and does not rely on the prose `message` field for structured state. **Why this matters:** init is the bootstrapping surface automation uses to ensure a project is claw-ready. If skip classification requires parsing human prose and the structured payload has two redundant formats, claws either over-provision re-inits or cannot distinguish safe skips from blocked writes without brittle message scraping. Source: Jobdori live dogfood, `e939777f`, 2026-04-30.